Introduction
Before we start comparing these two policies we have to set out some ground rules.
Both products are marketed by different insurance companies. Comprehensive is sold by Star Health and Optima Secure is sold by HDFC Ergo. So any meaningful comparison should include a comparison of the product alongside the insurers themselves.
Second, we know that both products are reasonably comprehensive. They do the basics quite well, but they won’t have all the bells and whistles (Think extensive coverage for international, dental, maternity and other such matters). So if you are looking for something else entirely, then both these policies may not cut it.
And finally, any comparison is ultimately futile without considering the use case. Who are you buying this policy for? You, your family, your parents?
That’s something you’ll need to answer before using this guide. So with that introduction out of the way, we can get to comparing the actual policies themselves.
Let’s start with Comprehensive. The product comes from Star Health’s stable:
Star Health Insurance is India's first standalone health insurance firm. And with an army of retail advisors pushing their products across the country, they’ve managed to capture a fair share of the Indian market.
The company also boasts a network of over 13,000+ hospitals and a decent claim settlement ratio of 83.07%.
Optima Secure meanwhile comes from HDFC Ergo’s stable:
Founded in the year 2002, the company is a joint venture between India’s HDFC and Germany’s ERGO International AG. It offers policies across motor, travel, health and other sectors. And it also happens to be one of the largest insurers in the country.
More importantly, HDFC Ergo boasts a claim settlement ratio of 97.55%, with a network of 11,300+ hospitals
All in all, an impressive resume.
Talk to IRDAI-certified experts
If you want help with selecting the best health policy tailored to your needs, book a FREE call with our experts today by clicking here.
Compare Insurances Insurance Parameters |  Comprehensive |  Optima Secure |
|---|---|---|
| Network hospitals | 14,000+ | 11,300+ |
| Claim settlement ratio (avg. of last 3 years) | 82.01% | 97.5% |
| Co-payment | 10% (if purchased after turning 61) | No |
| Room rent | Single Private room | Any Room |
| Disease sub-limit | No | No |
| Pre existing diseases waiting | 3 years | 3 years |
| Pre/Post hospitalization | 60/90 days | 60/180 days |
| No claim bonus | 50% per year (up to 100%) | 50% per year (up to 100%) |
| Domiciliary | ||
| Ayush treatments | ||
| Restoration benefit | 100% restoration (once for any illness after complete exhaustion of sum insured) | 100% restoration (once for any illness) |
| Health check-up | Once every year | Once every year |
| Maternity | Available (up to ₹20,000 after 2 years) | |
| Out Patient Department | Up to ₹1,200 (cap of ₹300 on each consultation) | |
| Day care |
Feature Comparison
Co payment
With a co-payment clause, the insurer will mandate that you pay a part of the bill. So if the bill adds up to Rs. 2,00,000 and the co-payment is set at 20% then you could be asked to pay Rs. 40,000 from the bill. In this case, however, Comprehensive requires you to co-pay a part of the bill 10% if you purchase after turning 61 whereas Optima Secure doesn’t impose a co-payment clause
Room rent
If the policy does impose room rent restrictions then the insurer may only let you stay in a room of a certain specification or impose a cap on the total room rent. If you were to breach either criterion then the insurance company may ask you to pay a portion of all the expenses you incurred while staying in the room. In this case, however, Comprehensive only lets you stay in a single private room but you can pick any room you want with Optima Secure.
Sub limits
Some policies will tell you that they will cover all medical expenses up until the sum insured, but then impose caps on the total costs you can incur while dealing with a very specific list of diseases. We call these caps “Disease Wise Sub Limits.” In this case, neither Comprehensive imposes disease-wise sub-limits nor does Optima Secure
Waiting periods for pre-existing diseases
If you’re suffering from a lifestyle condition or if you’ve had surgery in the past, or if you’re dealing with an acute or chronic illness at the time of buying the policy, then the insurer may classify this as a pre-existing disease. And they may tell you that they will only cover these illnesses after some time. This cooling period is referred to as the Pre-existing-disease waiting period. In this case, Comprehensive imposes a 3 year waiting period on pre-existing diseases and Optima Secure will similarly tell you to wait 3 years before making a claim related to your pre-existing diseases
Pre and post Hospitalization expenses
Most people aren’t hospitalized right off the bat. Instead, they’ll have to go through a whole series of diagnostic tests before hospitalization and take medication post-discharge. These costs are outlined as pre-hospitalization expenses and post-hospitalization expenses respectively. In this case, Comprehensive covers expenses incurred 60 days before hospitalization and expenses incurred 90 days post-hospitalization. Meanwhile, Optima Secure covers expenses incurred 60 days before hospitalization and expenses incurred 180 after hospitalization, although there may be different sub-limits
No claim bonus
Some policies will tell you that they will incentivize you for not making a claim in any given year. And they offer such incentives by offering extra cover on top of the existing sum insured. This extra cover is categorized as a no-claim bonus. And in this case, Comprehensive offers a no-claim bonus of 50% and Optima Secure similarly extends a 50% no-claim bonus.
Domiciliary
Imagine you are forced to treat yourself at home because you don’t find a hospital bed, or you have a chronic condition that prevents you from visiting one, then, insurers may choose to cover your treatment even if you’re hospitalized at home. And such costs are collectively categorized as domiciliary treatment costs. In this case, however, Comprehensive offers domiciliary cover. And Optima Secure also coves domiciliary expenses.
Ayush treatments
Most policies only cover treatments administered in a registered medical facility. However, on some occasions, you may want to pursue alternative treatments including homoeopathy, Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha. These treatments are collectively categorized as Ayush treatments. And in this case, Comprehensive covers Ayush procedures and Optima Secure also extends coverage for Ayush treatments.
Maternity benefits
If you’re hospitalized during childbirth, then you may have to incur significant costs during delivery of your newborn, child care and other related matters during the course of the hospitalization. These costs are collectively termed maternity costs. And in this case, however, Comprehensive offers maternity cover whereas Optima Secure doesn’t offer protection for maternity-related hospitalizations.
Out Patient Department (OPD)
Doctor visits and regular consultations aren’t usually covered by health insurance policies. They are categorized as Outpatient consultations (or OPD treatments) and patients have to bear the cost on their own. In this case, however, Comprehensive offers OPD cover whereas Optima Secure doesn’t offer OPD protection.
Final Conclusion
After considering all the features on hand and the claim settlement ratio of HDFC Ergo, we believe that Optima Secure is a better alternative to Comprehensive for most use cases that we’ve evaluated so far.
Other Star Health Comprehensive Comparisons
Other HDFC Ergo Optima Secure Comparisons
Select the best plan with our help!
Get in touch to find out what plan works best for you. Zero fuss. Zero spam. Zero charges. Book a call now. Limited slots available!