Health Insurance

ICICI Lombard vs. Care Health Insurance: Which Is Better?

Subhashish Banerjee

Written by Subhashish Banerjee

Insurance Writer

Gaurav Bhat

Reviewed by Gaurav Bhat

IRDAI-Certified Expert at Ditto

SP0738578124

Certified
ICICI Lombard vs. Care Health Insurance: Which Is Better?

Overview

ICICI Lombard and Care are established players in India’s health insurance market. When comparing ICICI Lombard vs. Care Health Insurance, check features along with key metrics.

Insurer Profiles

  • Insurer Type: ICICI Lombard is a private-sector general insurer. Care Health is a standalone health insurance company.
  • Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR): For FY 2024–26, Care reported a higher CSR of 95.45% than ICICI Lombard’s 86.81%.

Flagship Plans: ICICI Lombard Elevate and Care Supreme

  • Room Rent Restrictions: Supreme offers any-room eligibility. Elevate only covers a single private AC room unless you opt for a room modifier.
  • Pre- and Post-Hospitalization: Elevate covers 90 days before and 180 days after hospitalization. Supreme covers 60 days before and 180 days after hospitalization.

Pros and Cons

  • ICICI Lombard: Lower complaint volume compared with Care Health but operates at a lower CSR.
  • Care: Specialized focus on health insurance. However, premiums can be higher for comparable coverage.

Choosing between ICICI Lombard Health Insurance and Care Health Insurance can be tricky, especially when both offer comprehensive health plans with useful benefits. While ICICI Lombard brings the experience of a large general insurer, Care Health specializes in health coverage. 

In this guide, we compare Care Health Insurance vs. ICICI Lombard on performance across key operational metrics, flagship plan features, and pros and cons to help you decide which insurer is better. 

About the Insurers

ICICI Lombard Health Insurance

Established in 2000, ICICI Lombard began insurance operations in 2001. It is a private-sector general insurer headquartered in Mumbai, Maharashtra, with IRDAI registration number 115. The company offers health, motor, travel, property, marine, and other general insurance products.

Care Health Insurance

Incorporated in 2007 and licensed in 2012, Care Health Insurance was formerly known as Religare Health Insurance. It is a standalone health insurance company focused on health, personal accident, and travel insurance, with a significant presence in India’s retail health insurance market.

ICICI Lombard and Care Health: Performance Metrics

Metrics (FY 2024-26)ICICI LombardCareIndustry Average
Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) 86.81%95.45%92.02% 
Incurred Claims Ratio (ICR) (Average FY 2023–25) 79.47%58.68%81.88% 
Complaints Received per 10,000 Claims 15.0542.6729.35
Annual Business - Total Health (In Crore) ₹7,955.27₹8,404.67₹4,504.48
Network Hospitals 11,000+11,400+10,000+ (Ditto’s Benchmark)

Source: This information is sourced from the IRDAI annual reports, ICICI Lombard public disclosures, and Care public disclosures. For more insurer data, explore Ditto Data Lab.

Talk to an expert
today and find
the right
insurance for you.

Ditto Advisor

ICICI Lombard Elevate vs. Care Supreme: Key Features Compared

ICICI Lombard Elevate and Care Supreme are the insurers’ flagship comprehensive health insurance plans. Both offer extensive coverage and customizable add-ons, but differ in room eligibility, cumulative bonuses, and other benefits. 

    • Co-Payment and Disease-Wise Sub-Limits: Neither plan has a mandatory co-payment or disease-wise sub-limits. Both cover eligible treatment expenses up to the available sum insured, so you do not have to share the bill through a compulsory co-payment.
    • Sum Insured: Elevate offers options from a ₹5 lakh base cover to unlimited coverage. On the other hand, Care Supreme offers the base cover from ₹5 lakh to ₹1 crore. Both plans cover domiciliary treatment, daycare procedures, and AYUSH treatment, subject to policy terms.
    • Room Rent Restrictions: Elevate covers a single private a/c room by default, but you can upgrade room eligibility through an optional add-on. Care Supreme has no specific room rent restriction, giving you greater flexibility in choosing a hospital room.
    • Pre- and Post-Hospitalization: Both plans cover eligible medical expenses for up to 180 days after hospitalization. Elevate provides 90 days of pre-hospitalization coverage, while Care Supreme covers expenses for up to 60 days before hospitalization.
    • Restoration Benefit: Both plans offer 100% restoration of the sum insured, unlimited times for any illness. The benefit can restore the full sum insured for future hospitalizations, subject to policy conditions. However, the conditions for triggering these benefits differ between the plans.
    • In-Built Bonus: Elevate increases your sum insured by 20% each year, even if you make a claim. Care Supreme, on the other hand, offers a 50% annual increase, even after claims, subject to its applicable limits. However, the bonus stops once the accumulated increase reaches 100% of the base sum insured under both plans. 
Background Image

Important Add-ons Offered

01

Cumulative Bonus

Elevate’s Power Booster adds 100% of the sum insured every year, with no upper limit, even if you make a claim. Supreme’s Cumulative Bonus Super also adds 100% each year, up to 500% of the sum insured, regardless of claims. With Care Supreme, you can opt for the Cumulative Bonus Booster add-on, which increases your sum insured by 100% each year without any upper limit, subject to policy terms.

02

Wellness Benefit

Supreme offers a renewal premium discount of up to 30% for maintaining a healthy lifestyle as an add-on. Elevate offers a built-in wellness benefit that lets policyholders earn up to 30% off their renewal premium for the following year (subject to terms and conditions).

03

Consumable Coverage

Elevate offers the Claim Protector add-on, which covers listed non-medical items under List I. Supreme offers similar coverage through its Claim Shield Plus add-on.

04

Annual Health Check-Up

Both plans offer an annual health check-up add-on that covers specified tests. You can use it on a cashless basis.

05

Room Upgrade

Elevate offers a Room Rent Modifier add-on that lets you change from a single private room to any room or twin-sharing room.

06

Air Ambulance

Supreme covers emergency air ambulance expenses up to ₹5 lakh per policy year. Elevate offers a Domestic Air Ambulance Cover add-on.

Note: Apart from their flagship plans, ICICI Lombard and Care Health offer other health insurance options with different coverage features and benefits. You can also explore plans such as ICICI Lombard Health AdvantEdge and Ultimate Care.

Sample Premiums Comparison by Age and Cover

The table below uses A for adults and C for children. These are indicative premiums for a Delhi resident (pincode: 110010) with ₹15 lakh coverage, including recommended add-ons and applicable discounts. Actual premiums may vary based on age, city, medical history, and selected add-ons.

ProfilesICICI Lombard ElevateCare Supreme
(Individual Plan): Age 25₹13,042₹16,294
(Family Floater, 2A): Ages (31, 32)₹19,490₹23,153
(Family Floater, 2A 1C): Ages (35, 34, 5)₹25,472₹29,257
(Family Floater, 2A): Ages (62, 63)₹79,965₹86,069

Pros and Cons of ICICI Lombard and Care Health

Pros of ICICI Lombard

    • Lower complaint volume compared with Care Health and the industry average.
    • Strong financial backing from the ICICI Group.

Cons of ICICI Lombard

    • Smaller health insurance business compared with Care Health.
    • In-built bonus increases are limited to 20% up to 100% under the standard option.

Pros of Care Health

    • Care Health Insurance claim settlement ratio is higher than ICICI Lombard Health Insurance claim settlement ratio and the industry average.
    • Flexible room eligibility with no room rent restriction under Care Supreme.

Cons of Care Health

    • Lower incurred claims ratio than ICICI Lombard and the industry average.
    • Premiums can be higher for comparable coverage and policy terms.

Why Choose Ditto for Health Insurance?

At Ditto, we’ve assisted over 12,00,000 customers with choosing the right insurance policy. Why customers like Pallavi love us:

Pallavi Nayak LinkedIn Testimonial
    • 100% Free Consultation
    • No Spam. No Sales Pressure.
    • Rated 4.9/5 on Google Reviews by 30,000+ Happy Customers
    • Backed by Zerodha
    • Dedicated Claim Support Team
    • Compare Plans and Premiums with a Trusted Insurance Advisor

Confused about the right insurance? Speak to Ditto’s certified advisors for free, unbiased guidance. Book your call now or chat with us on WhatsApp. Slots fill up fast!

Conclusion

ICICI Lombard is a well-established general insurer with strong financial backing and lower complaint levels. Its Elevate plan offers useful customization options and broader pre-hospitalization coverage. However, its claim settlement ratio is lower than Care Health's.

Care Health stands out with a higher claim settlement ratio and flexible room eligibility. After considering the features and insurer metrics, we believe Care Supreme is a better fit for most use cases reviewed. It is also among the best health insurance plans worth considering.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Care Supreme better than ICICI Lombard Elevate for a family floater policy?

Care Supreme may suit families who value room flexibility, as it offers any-room eligibility under its standard configuration. It also provides a built-in cumulative bonus of 50% each year, up to 100% of the base sum insured. ICICI Lombard Elevate offers 90 days of pre-hospitalization coverage, compared with Care Supreme’s 60 days, along with unlimited sum insured options. The final choice should depend on your family's medical needs, preferred hospitals, add-ons, and the premiums quoted for comparable cover. You can explore Care Health Insurance reviews.

Can I port my Care Health Insurance policy to ICICI Lombard without losing waiting period benefits?

Yes. You can port your Care Health Insurance policy to ICICI Lombard at renewal and retain eligible waiting period credits for the sum insured already covered. The new insurer will assess your application before accepting it. Apply within the prescribed portability window, ideally 30-60 days before renewal, and disclose your medical history accurately to avoid complications. Before porting, you can go through an ICICI Lombard health insurance review.

Which insurer has a larger cashless hospital network in Tier 2 Cities, Care Health or ICICI Lombard?

There is no reliable basis for declaring one insurer the winner across all Tier-2 cities. Both operate with over 11,000 hospitals. However, these figures do not establish which insurer has better coverage in Tier-2 cities. You can check the ICICI Lombard hospital locator and the Care hospital locator for your city and preferred hospitals before buying.

Which insurer offers a better no-claim Bonus, Care Health or ICICI Lombard?

Care Health offers a better built-in bonus coverage. ICICI Lombard Elevate increases the sum insured by 20% annually, while Care Supreme offers a 50% annual increase, subject to the respective plan limits. Both plans offer optional add-ons to increase these limits further, subject to policy terms.

Do Care Health and ICICI Lombard have the same waiting period for pre-existing diseases?

Yes. Both Care Supreme and ICICI Lombard Elevate have a 36-month waiting period for pre-existing diseases under their standard terms. However, both plans offer optional covers that may reduce certain waiting periods. Check the latest policy wording and selected add-ons to understand the waiting period applicable to your conditions.

Which insurer is better for senior citizens, Care Health or ICICI Lombard?

Neither insurer is automatically better for senior citizens. Compare Care Supreme and ICICI Lombard Elevate based on pre-existing disease coverage, co-payment clauses, room eligibility, premiums, and nearby cashless hospitals. Also, check whether the policy imposes age-based restrictions or additional underwriting requirements before deciding.

Does ICICI Lombard offer better coverage for modern treatments than Care Health?

Both ICICI Lombard Elevate and Care Supreme cover specified modern treatments, subject to their respective policy terms and exclusions. Coverage may extend up to the available sum insured for eligible procedures. Review the list of covered treatments and any procedure-specific restrictions before deciding which plan suits your healthcare needs.

Which insurer offers better coverage for daycare treatments, Care Health or ICICI Lombard?

Both Care Supreme and ICICI Lombard Elevate cover eligible daycare procedures that do not require 24-hour hospitalization. However, coverage depends on the procedure meeting the policy's definition and conditions. Check the respective policy wordings for exclusions and restrictions rather than relying only on the number of covered procedures.

Is Care Health Insurance the same as Religare Health Insurance?

Yes. Care Health Insurance was previously known as Religare Health Insurance. The company rebranded as Care Health Insurance in 2020. It continues to operate as a standalone health insurance provider in India. If you have an older Religare policy, its coverage and benefits remain subject to the applicable policy terms and conditions.

Last updated on: